Tomáš Akvinský
Studia Neoaristotelica


ROČNÍK 4 (2007)ČÍSLO 2

PERSPEKTIVY LOGICKÉ SÉMANTIKY JANA BURIDANA
Miroslav Hanke


SUMMARIUM
Semantica logicalis Iohannis Buridani,
eiusque explicatio necnon censura

Huius dissertationis scopus est analysis terminologiae logico-semanticae, quae Iohannes Buridanus (c. 1295–1360), logicus mediaevalis ad scholam Nominalium spectans, utitur. Inquisitio haec praecipue circa conceptus „causae veritatis“ et „consequentiae“ versatur, ad quos conceptus autem clarificandos duo apparent praerequisita: primo quidem explicatio significationis terminorum modalium (ut quid sit neessitas, quid possibilitas), secundo solutio (saltem attemptata) „insolubilium“ seu (ut moderni aiunt) paradoxorum semanticorum, ut paradoxi Epimenidis. Ex analysi Buridani discursus patet, eius intellegentiam logicae de facto parum successisse, propter errores nonnulos in analysi conceptuali modalis semanticaeque terminologiae. Auctor igitur aliam explicationem notionis consequentiae proponit, quam ex conceptione semantica modalitatis, qua Buridanus implicite tantum innixus est, hausit. Auctor credit hanc explicationem possibilitatem aperit, systema logicum, quod conceptualiter et consequenter explicative „clausum“ sit, conficere.



SUMMARY
Perspectives of the Logical Semantics of Jean Buridan

The subject of the present article is the analysis of fundamental logical-semantical terminology of late-medieval nominalistic logician Jean Buridan (c. 1295–1360). The analysis focuses on the concepts of truth conditions and logical consequence, whose clarification presupposes explication of modal terminology as well as a solution of semantical antinomies such as “Liar” (or an attempt to solve them). The analysis of Buridan’s argumentation suggests that Buridan’s project of logic actually fails due to several failures of conceptual analysis of semantical and modal terminology. An alternative solution of the question concerning logical consequence is thus proposed in terms of Buridan’s implicit (and unused) semantical conception of modalities that makes it possible to establish conceptually and therefore explicatively closed logical framework.










Jan Duns Scotus